Cherry Street Diner

You can purchase past years' pennies 2005-2016 at the Cherry St Diner or by emailing [email protected] .They are bagged and for sale at 50 cents per penny, $1.50 per set. They also have a set of Ashville, Ohio pennies bagged as well.

Current 2024 designs. this is a 3-die machine that takes $1 per coin (quarters), supply your own penny. Designs are:
1) Circleville Pumpkin Show 2018,
2) Circleville Pumpkin Show 2019,
3) Cherry Street Diner logo.

Retired designs:

Retired 2016 deisgn was: 1) H 'Circleville Pumpkin Show 2016' with 2 pumpkins.
Retired 2015 design was: 1) H 'Circleville Pumpkin Show 2015' with 2 pumpkins
Retired 2014 design was: 1) H 'Circleville Pumpkin Show 2014' with 2 pumpkins
Retired 2013 designs were: 1) H 'Circleville Pumpkin Show 2013' with 2 pumpkins, 2) H 'Peace' with dove, 3) H 'USA
Retired 2012 designs were: 1) H 'Circleville Pumpkin Show 2012' with pumpkin, 2) H 'In God We Trust' with eagle 3) V 'Obama Biden 2012' with donkey, 4) V 'Romney Ryan 2012 with elephant
Retired 2011 designs were: 1) H- 2011 'Circleville Pumpkin Show 2011' with 2 pumpkins, 2) H- 'Circleville Pumpkin Show 2011' water tower painted like pumpkin, 3) H- '105th Pumpkin Show' - pine tree shaped tower of pumpkins
Retired 2010 designs were: 1) H-'Circleville Pumpkin Show', pumpkins and wagon wheel. 2) H- 'Pickaway County 1810-2010', Indian Chief, 3) H- 'Pickaway County Bicentenial 1810-2010', Court House.
Retired 2009 designs were: 1) H- 'The Great Seal of the State of Ohio', 2) Liberty Bel l- 'Let Freedom Ring', 3) 2009 'Cirlcleville Pumpkin Show' with 2 pumpkins (same design as last year but with 2009 date).
Retired 2008 designs were: 1) H-pumpkins and '2008 Circleville Pumpkin Show', 2) V- 'Obama and Biden' 2008, 3) V- 'McClain and Palin' 2008.
Retired 2007 designs were: 1) H-'Circleville Pumpin Show 2007', 2) H-Pumpkin Character, 'Circleville Pumpkin Show', 3) H-Democrat and Republican/Donkey and Elephant-We are Americans First, 4) V-Lord's Prayer. The 2007
Retired 2006 designs were: 1) H '100th Circleville Pumpkin Show with large pumpkin, 2) H '100th Circleville Pumpkin Show with arch and pumpkin, 3) H 'God Bless America' with flag.
Retired 2005: designs were: 1) H 'Pumpkin Show Circleville Ohio' with three pumpkins, 2) H 'Circleville Ohio Est. 1836' with original town circle, 3) V 'Best Friends'

7/27/25: Still works great! They had plenty of previous sets as well